Dave's retirement journey

How reliable are these financial rules of thumb?

By Dave Dineen, BrighterLife.ca

Are financial rules of thumb useful? Very. Are they precise? No. See how 15 common pieces of advice measure up.

How reliable are these financial rules of thumb?When I was a kid growing up on a farm, I learned that not every task requires great precision. Once, my dad asked me to stack hay 30 feet inside the barn door. I didn’t look for a tape measure. Instead — knowing my strides are about three feet long — I took 10 strides from the door and got to work.

There are lots of financial “rules of thumb” designed for the same reason: to give you a rough idea of what to aim for, so you can get to the work of achieving your financial goal.

I find financial rules of thumb thought-provoking and sometimes action-provoking. But if you expect a financial rule of thumb to give you an accurate answer for your personal situation, you’re using it wrong. No rule of thumb is that reliable.

Sometimes “-ish” is okay

There are times when it’s okay to settle for information that is only directionally right. For example, if you’re 45, it’s reassuring if a rule of thumb suggests you’re on track to retire at your goal of 65-ish. I think it’s also okay to estimate whether the annual retirement income you can expect to start in 20 years would be $40,000-ish or $60,000-ish.

In contrast, if you’re thinking of retiring within the next five years, you need crisp, reliable answers that don’t end in “-ish.” Here’s my take on the reliability of various financial rules of thumb:

  1. Your retirement income needs to be 70% of your working income.
    Unreliable. It’s a one-size-fits-none rule. Instead, identify which expenses will disappear when you retire (such as transportation to work or RRSP contributions). Also, will your retirement lifestyle be on the costly side (travelling around the world) or the frugal side (growing your own vegetables)? My wife and I highly recommend this three-step exercise. Consider: 1. the lifestyle you want and what it will cost; 2. how your expenses will change; and 3. what your income needs to be. This isn’t a replacement for a financial plan, but it’s a start.
  2. Keep an emergency fund equal to six months’ income.
    Somewhat reliable. A six-month fund would be handy if you had a temporary job loss or your car needed a major repair. But having no credit card debt and having access to a line of credit would also help in a short-term emergency. Insurance is the best way to protect against catastrophes (such as death or critical illness) that six months’ savings won’t cover.
  3. Don’t pay more than 3.5 times your gross annual income for your house.
    Fairly reliable. This should give you the financial latitude to tackle other goals, such as saving for your kids’ education or your retirement. In expensive real estate markets, this is a tough rule to live by. In my working days, we compromised and chose to work and live largely outside of the expensive Greater Toronto Area.
  4. Don’t invest more than 5% of your savings in any one stock or bond.
    100% reliable. My cousin Johnny “bet the farm” on a particular tech stock when it was Canada’s darling. (Actually, as a farmer, he bet everything but the farm.) When the stock crashed, so did a huge chunk of his net worth. I’ve also been burned when I’ve invested heavily in exciting investments that made headlines.
  5. Accumulate 20 times your gross annual income, then retire.
    Reliable but not realistic. I was able to save 10 times my annual income, but I wouldn’t use that as a rule of thumb, either.
  6. Never touch your retirement savings, except for retirement.
  7. In retirement, you can sustainably live off of 4% of your nest egg.
    This is controversial. With today’s low interest rates and Canadians’ greater longevity, some experts warn that with a 4% payout, you may still run out of money someday. As an early retiree, it’s been especially vital for me to monitor my payout rate, because my nest egg will have to last longer. In my first three years in retirement, it was 2.95%, 3.32% and 2.97%. (Disclosure: On top of those payouts, I also earned some money from a bit of freelance work. I don’t think most people could retire comfortably on 3% of their nest egg alone.) Another consideration is the potential for significant, unexpected health care costs. Really, you need a financial plan to guide you on sustainability.
  8. If your employer matches your contributions to a workplace savings plan, go for it.
    Absolutely! Sacrifice other things, but make this happen. It’s like getting a guaranteed return and extra income.
  9. The percentage of your portfolio in bonds and fixed-income investments should be equal to your age.
    Hmm . . . that advice worked better when bond yields were higher. (As a reminder, this rule of thumb says that if you’re 55, you should have 55% of your portfolio in relatively safe bonds/fixed investments/cash and the other 45% in equities.) I’m 58 and I wouldn’t be getting enough income in today’s environment if 57% of my investments were in bonds. The flip side is that being more heavily invested in equities is riskier.
  10. Total home ownership costs shouldn’t exceed 30% of your gross income.
    Pretty reliable. This includes mortgage payments, home insurance, heat/hydro/water, property taxes and condo fees. If you limit your housing costs, you can consider other goals in life — not just having a house.
  11. Your total debt servicing costs shouldn’t exceed 40% of your income.
    I like this one, too. This includes everything in the 30% list just above, plus payments on car loans, credit cards and other debt. Following this rule made it possible for my wife and me to save for retirement and for our kids’ education.
  12. Don’t plan to retire with debt.
    I agree 100%.
  13. You need to have x times your annual income in life insurance.
    Never rely on a life insurance rule of thumb. Instead, talk to a financial advisor about what you need. When I was working, I was our family’s sole income-earner. If I died, my wife and two kids would have had no income at all, so I saw buying life insurance as the most important financial decision we made.
  14.  Save for your retirement before your kids’ education.
    Probably reliable, but . . . only if you’re truly in an either/or situation. Ideally, do both. Remember that your kids can borrow to pay for school costs, but you can’t borrow to retire.
  15. If you carry a credit card balance, find the lowest-interest-rate card. If you don’t carry a balance, find the lowest-cost or highest-reward card.
    Totally reliable.

Readers, what do you think? Any quibbles with my assessments of these rules of thumb? Are there any I’ve missed that you rely on — or would hate to rely on?

Financial planning Check out more financial planning tips and tools.
Retirement savings Get more bright ideas on saving for retirement.
Planning for a long life Get more tips and tools to help you live a longer, healthier life.

Stay connected

Get more tips and tools to help you live brighter.

Enter your email address below:

Learn more

When's the best time to start drawing CPP/QPP benefits?

Do the math with our CPP/QPP calculator.

Take action

Are you on track to meet your financial and retirement planning goals?

It's never too early or too late to start!

For a FREE review of your financial plan: Talk to an Advisor.

Leo Boileau on

Fully agree with your comments but I would also add that everyone or every family should consider developing a budget based on past expenses and future plans. This way one learns to respect the value of a dollar.

Jim Barnard on

Preparing your retirement home while you still have working cash flow will reduce many “surprises” in retirement. Replace the roof with new 40 year shingles, new windows and doors with 20 year guarantees, vinyl siding and sofits, rather than wood and paint. We should still be prepared to spend 1%ish of the value of your home each year in maintenance cost.

    davedineen on

    Jim, my friend, that’s excellent advice. Even if you’re a do-it-yourselfer, get the paying-it-yourself out of the way before you’re retired and relying on what is usually reduced income.

Robert on

My father died when I was 10 with zero insurance. My mother had to find work to support herself, my sister( 14) and myself. We were the poor kids in the neighborhood. One thing that she did instill was that you DO NOT buy anything unless you have the cash in hand. The exceptions would be a necessity like if the fridge or furnace failed. I lived by that rule while putting my 2 boys though university (one through law school) and now we enjoy a very comfortable retirement.

    davedineen on

    Robert — that’s a really safe, sleep-at-night, approach. Well done.

Ryan on

Love it all! Well done. I like how you point out that no one rule of thumb fits everyone. I think people without a financial background get a good rule in their head, and go overboard trying to live by it 100% of the time. We’re all unique, and as such, we need to tailor financial rules to our uniqueness. I really think you captured this concept in the article!

    davedineen on

    Ryan — thanks for the kind comments.

Michele on

Hmm – I’d add to the list “Aim to keep your committed spending (needs plus wants that you’re contractually obligated to keep paying for – like cell-phone payments) below 50% of your take-home pay (if your take-home varies wildly, then below 50% of your reliable take-home pay)”

That leaves the other 50% for long term savings / investing / building up an emergency fund AND for discretionary spending. And it means that, in a pinch, you could survive on half your income for a while.

    davedineen on

    Michele — I like your approach but I suspect that for most folks, it only becomes achievable when you get past those early spending years (buying a car, paying for education, buying/furnishing a home). It really adds to financial security and peace of mind, for sure.

      Michele on

      Agreed, it would definitely be challenging for most people. But it’s a question that could be added to the decision-making process – “if I buy this car, with monthly payments of $X, will it increase my committed monthly spending to more than 50% of my take-home pay?”

      In a way, it’s an extension of your rules (10) AND (11) – just add in gym memberships and cellphone costs (ok, and groceries and a few other things)

Andrew Chong on

#8 and #14 somewhat conflict. By not contributing to an RESP up to the point of the government match, you are also giving away free money.

    davedineen on

    Andrew — Thanks. Not sure I see the conflict, but you’re right that I missed the point about the value of maximizing your RESP contributions, to take advantage of the Canada Education Savings Grant from the government. Good catch!

CanadianBudgetBinder (@CanadianBudgetB) on

I think you’ve nailed quite a few of them and some that your readers might not have thought of. I know people in my organization that don’t take part in our pension plan which is matched. I’m not sure why but like you mention it’s important to make that happen even if you have to cut back in other areas of the budget. It’s free money. I also agree retiring with no debt is important and likely another reason why some people can’t afford to retire when they thought they would. I don’t have a date or year on when I want to retire but what I do know is that I’m arming myself with as much information as I can now to make the transition as painless as I can.

Add a new comment:

Note: Please be sure to read our commenting policy and terms and conditions for this site. We reserve the right to delete any comments that we view to be in violation of our policy. The name you provide will appear next to your comment. Thank you!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Free financial review - Start now!
Get the Money for Life newsletter

Connect to your Brighter Life