Money

Budgeting, saving and investing for a brighter financial future

How much life insurance do you need?

By Deanne Gage, BrighterLife.ca

Comments (12)

Life insurance is something you don’t buy for yourself – you buy it for the benefit of others. When should you think about buying it? Certainly, when you get married, have children or have someone who is dependent on your income. Then the question is: How much do you need?

A baby is holding a parent's finger.Take a common-law couple in their early 30s we’ll call Carly and Jack. They have been in a relationship for three years and recently purchased a $350,000 two-bedroom condo in a Toronto suburb. But what if Jack suddenly died? It currently takes both Jack and Carly’s incomes to afford their $2,000 monthly mortgage payments and condo fees. Carly could sell the condo and downsize but she’d like to avoid that hassle. So, the couple decided to get life insurance to protect their new home. That way, Carly or Jack would have the money to pay off their mortgage if something happened to one of them.

Many people believe the coverage provided by their employer is sufficient. But let’s do the math. Your employer’s group insurer would likely pay your beneficiary three times your annual salary, at most. If you earn $70,000 a year, that’s $210,000. Let’s say you have a husband and two young children counting on that income for mortgage payments, daycare costs, education savings and day-to-day living expenses. It won’t take long for that lump sum to disappear.

So how much do you need? An insurance advisor will help you to fill out a needs analysis questionnaire to determine the appropriate amount, taking into consideration your annual income, net worth, debts and existing life insurance.

A general rule of thumb is you should be covered for at least 10 times your annual income, so if you earn $70,000, you’d be looking at $700,000 in coverage. But every individual situation is different and should be examined as such.

An analysis would determine what you need the money for, how much you need each month and how long you need it to last. Let’s take Jackie, a 39-year-old married mother of two. She has three goals for her insurance coverage:

  1. Pay off the $300,000 mortgage.
  2. Top up her two children’s registered education savings accounts.
  3. Replace her $60,000 income.

In simple terms, Jackie is looking at a $1 million policy. If she died, the money from her insurance could be spent this way:

  • $300,000 toward the mortgage
  • $100,000 toward the kids’ RESPs ($50,000 is the maximum amount you can contribute to an individual RESP).
  • $600,000 (her annual earnings times 10) to invest to cover day-to-day expenses that her husband Bob and children will incur over the years.

How term insurance works

Term life insurance provides temporary protection for temporary needs. Specific terms usually range from one to 20 years, so it can be an excellent, affordable option for parents with young children. For instance, a $1 million term policy on a woman in her late 30s like Jackie costs $77 per month. For a man of the same age, it’s closer to $111. Experts recommend 20-year term policies for younger couples who are buying their first homes, are recently married and have significant debt. For couples in their 40s who have little debt and have almost paid off their mortgages, 10-year term policies might be sufficient. Couples should consider joint-term, first-to-die policies, which insure two people and pay out on the death of the first insured person.

Jackie and her husband Bob decided they needed a $1 million, 20-year joint term first-to-die life policy, with a monthly premium cost of $177. They thought about going with a $500,000 life policy instead, but reconsidered at the last minute. With a significant mortgage to pay off, they wanted the security of knowing that in a worst-case scenario, they’d have that extra money for other needs.

In addition to providing affordable protection, term insurance also gives you some future flexibility. Most term insurance plans let you convert your term coverage to permanent insurance without having to answer any health-related questions. As long as your premiums are paid, your life insurance protection will stay in place for the rest of your life.

For more financial planning tips, check out:


When was the last time you reviewed your personal economic plan?
Talking with your advisor can help ensure you’re on track to meet your financial and retirement goals. Don’t have an advisor? Visit Sun Life Financial Advisor Match to help you find one in your area.

Learn more about available life insurance and mortgage protection insurance options. Use our life insurance calculator to get an idea of how much you might need to protect your loved ones.

Brian Poncelet,CFP on

The real question is how much insurance do you want, not need.

Here is an example: Let’s say your house worth $500,000 burns right down to the ground. Do you say just give me a trailer on the land and I am good with that?!

How about the car? You are in an accident and your 2008 Honda Accord is smashed by a another driver who has no insurance. Your insurance company replaces it with a 2001 Honda Accord because you just NEED 4 wheels!
Does this make sense?

Ok as a general rule take one’s income say $100,000 X years to retire let’s say 20 years. You will want at least $2,000,000. The biggest objection is cost! How about if some the coverage is permanent and for retirement you can increase your spendable retirement income by 19% and lower your tax bill by 37% and have less risk, and better protection. See if insurance is free how much do you want? The maximum you can get or zero? In the above case it is not free but neither is straight term…unless you die before the term is up then it is a great deal…but that is not most people’s plan.

Phil on

So in the example used in the article…
Let’s take Jackie, a 39-year-old married mother of two. She has three goals for her insurance coverage:
Jackie is looking at a $1 million policy. If she died, the money from her insurance could be spent this way:
•$300,000 toward the mortgage – hello, why, does the husband not work? are we expecting him not to work now? Also, with 1 less person in the picture, maybe the house is too big and they can downsize… maybe max $150K
•$100,000 toward the kids’ RESPs ($50,000 is the maximum amount you can contribute to an individual RESP). – again, hello, would you have not started already contributing to RESP’s, she is 39, so on average she might have had kids at 30, so 9 years of socking money away already 5Kx 9yrs = 45K, so again lets cut this to half and say $50K max…
•$600,000 (her annual earnings times 10) to invest to cover day-to-day expenses that her husband Bob and children will incur over the years. – Okay, so now that mom died, Bob does not need to work? Bob should still work as he will need the social interaction and something to remain normal in his life and get him out of the house, so unless mom was the sole bread winner, we need to assume they both had equal jobs, in which case $300K might be enough? Maybe Bob will meet someone else and remarry… even 300K might be too much…

Bottom line is want or need, insurance is expensive, and iff you are told by someone you need 1M, save a few bucks and understand statistics… half that would more than cover you. besides, you can always invest that extra $250/month for the extra coverage, and if you fit real statistics, you’ll have a little extra cash come retirement :)

    Brian Poncelet,CFP on

    Phil,

    If you buy the right type of insurance you get all your premiums back plus interest.

    You can increase your retirement spending money by 19% or more.

    You have better protection, less risk, less taxes.

    If you have limited cash flow then term is the best way to go. If you can, get a mix of both term and permanent.

      Phil on

      Brian,
      If you buy the right type… Well I do not currently have any life insurance… Ouch! Most would think that to be irresponsible I guess, but when we had our mortgage we had mortgage insurance, which covered the cost of the house while we were paying it down – $5.50/month over the 5 years it took to pay the mortgage… As to life insurance, we as a family decided what was the need? Basic coverage was covered by our employment, which covered any funeral costs and I recall it was 2x salary, which was nice since if one of us passed, it would have meant that for 2 years, the living part of the family would have had a free ride, since we planed our lives to live on the need of only 1 of our working salaries to survive. Insurance costs money, and to your point above that you get all your premiums back + interest… okay, technically yes, but along the way you lost all the compounding if you had invested it. Again know your insurance needs for you situation. For us all we wanted was to have was the basics covered – the house, which is now paid and basic funeral costs, which now our investments more than cover… Anything beyond that cuts into our life’s enjoyment, and the want to retire early to actually ENJOY LIFE. Cheers.

      Brian@rightinsurance.ca on

      Hello Phil,

      Your statement

      ” Again know your insurance needs for you situation. For us all we wanted was to have was the basics covered – the house, which is now paid and basic funeral costs, which now our investments more than cover… Anything beyond that cuts into our life’s enjoyment, and the want to retire early to actually ENJOY LIFE. Cheers.”

      You may want to read my story in Million Dollar Journey “How annuities work”. Insurance really is a want product, if cash flow is tight then term maybe your only choice.

      People who are self-employed or incorporated generally understand taxes can do a lot of damage to real returns because they don’t have that come off their pay cheque. Nothing personal, generally they view things differently than people who are on a salary. So I understand where you are coming from.

      If you want to get all your money back plus interest (on premiums paid) you may want to review that.
      I am working on a new story which in a nutshell shows unless you can get 8% every year in retirement (no corrections like 2008) the “buy term and invest the difference” does not work. I expect this to be out late February or March.

      Again the goal is pay less taxes, have better protection, less risk and spend more money in retirement then insurance (permanent) is what you may want unless your returns is at least 8% (after fees, taxes) in retirement.

Pete on

This is a wonderful discussion thread. I think it all comes down to individual needs of people. The standard formulas that the insurance industry uses are inadequate. Life Insurance is a personal affair. I think that as long as the sales agent does the best to sell life that benefits the customer and not their own pockets, then they can live guilt free. I like the inflation factor in the calculations. Pehaps the biggest benefit you can give to people is to take care of their own health. It is pointless to have 2 million but no health to enjoy it. Thanks all for sharing.

    Brian Poncelet,CFP on

    Pete,

    Term insurance is like renting nothing wrong with that everyone has to start somewhere.

    You may want to read “How annuites work” in Million Dollar Journey.

    In a nutshell, you can get a high guaranteed rate of return at retirement (65) at over 6.6% for the rest of your life and pay 20% less taxes.

    Insurance is really for two things if you die early or live a long time.

Add a new comment:

Note: Please be sure to read our commenting policy and terms and conditions for this site. We reserve the right to delete any comments that we view to be in violation of our policy. The name you provide will appear next to your comment. Thank you!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Money for Life - Achieving lifetime financial security
Free newsletter subscription
Sun Life is Reader's Digest most-trusted life insurance brand

Connect to your Brighter Life