Today's economy

15 extreme risks and what they mean for you

By Kevin Press, BrighterLife.ca

Comments (6)

If the 21st century has taught us anything, it is that extraordinary things happen. The new edition of Towers Watson’s Extreme Risks report details 15 whoppers. Not surprisingly, given the global consulting firm’s excellent reputation, the report is written in measured, conservative language. Still, it is a fascinating read.

Image of a compass and Euro currency signifying the risks the European economy pose to the world economy and individual Canadian investors.The risks are measured in terms of impact and likelihood. Those judged most likely, relative to the others, are a banking crisis, depression, currency crisis, a breakup of the eurozone (in which at least one member country exits) and protectionism (as in a reversal of free trade). In the firm’s opinion, a depression would have a high impact. A currency crisis and euro breakup would have a medium impact. And a rise in protectionism would have a low impact.

I spoke with Janet Rabovsky, director, investment consulting at Towers Watson about the report. Here’s a condensed Q&A.

What’s the purpose of this report?

Our working premise is that we think bad things are going to continue to happen more and more frequently. We think there’s going to be some sort of major event every few years. And that’s simply because there’s such an interconnectedness now of economies and markets. For example, we identified the breakup of the euro a few years ago. It was something that we thought had a low probability at the time, but could obviously have disastrous results. That’s gone up in our ranking as there is a real possibility.

Image of a chart showing the levels of financial and economic risks as presented in the Towers Watson report.

How concerned are you about a sovereign default?

We actually think it could happen. The world is working very closely – the International Monetary Fund, the European Financial Stability Facility, all the different groups – to try and prevent a default. Technically, Greece is pretty much insolvent. But that issue is relatively small. What everybody’s concerned about right now is Italy. There’s nobody that could absorb that. For those countries that default, the cost of borrowing increases. We’ve already seen that with the cost of French debt and Italian debt. And then there’s a lack of support among investors. It’s almost like a self-fulfilling prophecy. If a major country like Italy defaulted, that’s a big problem. There’s no ability for the current financial system to absorb that default.

What kind of effect would a euro breakup cause?

It would have a massive impact. But I think it’s somewhat calibrated because we don’t think it’s going to happen in the near-term. If you look at the amount of time, money and effort invested by Germany and France; everybody wants to try and make this work. There may be a way that Greece exits in an orderly fashion in the next few years, but nobody else is going to at this point.

Megan Greene of Roubini Global Economics, who has predicted a eurozone breakup, said the impact on the global financial system would be a “Lehman-times-five event.” Do you agree?

I can’t calibrate it, but that seems reasonable. There’s so much interconnectedness. You’ve got people holding European debt, people holding European equities. All the contracts, all the businesses; think about all the work that went into getting them to the euro. Exiting would be a nightmare.

A banking crisis is more likely now than it was in your 2009 report, which you link to a slow economic recovery.

Europe is teetering on the edge of recession again, if it’s not already in recession. Certainly the U.S. is coming out, but it’s slow. And interest rates in North America and in Europe remain artificially low. So what you have then is an impingement on the banks’ ability to make money. Banks make money by lending money out. Their cost is paying the depositors that they’re borrowing from. Right now, there’s not enough spread for them. They need higher rates and bigger margins. Their earnings have compressed. Now, think about all the changes to traditional banking and investment banking. They can no longer subsidize this business with their investment banking earnings because of the financial turmoil and because they’re precluded from doing certain things. The other reason that their balance sheets are impacted is that they own a lot of U.S. and European real estate that they don’t want to own. In Europe specifically, a lot of the banks were given attractive incentives to buy European debt which takes us back to the euro issue again. Now that debt’s not worth 100 cents on the dollar. So it’s a bit of a mess.

What are the key messages here for Canadian investors?

We think that there are going to be market-turmoil events that will occur every few years. As an investor, you need to decide whether you are constructing your investment portfolio for what you expect or for the worst-case outcome. Thinking about risk tolerance, time horizon and cash flow is really important. Do you have a stable job? Could you up your contributions? What stage of life are you in? If you are on contract as opposed to in a full-time job or if you have just a few years until retirement, you may want to have a less risky portfolio to mitigate some of these things that could potentially happen. It’s up to the individual to assess how they want to construct their portfolio. We are definitely going to have more of these events. I think being more aware; understanding what the influences are and what happens if things don’t go as you planned is important. Maybe save more and be less risky. We’re certainly telling our pension funds that. Accept a higher cost for greater certainty. Take out some of the volatility. Don’t be so reliant on equities. Equity volatility – you’re going to get there, but it’s going to be a heck of a ride.


When was the last time you reviewed your personal economic plan? Talking with your advisor can help ensure you’re on track to meet your financial and retirement goals. Don’t have an advisor? Visit Sun Life Financial Advisor Match to help you find one in your area.

Stay connected

Stay connected. Get inspired.

Follow Today's economy on RSS.

Sign up for the monthly Brighter Life newsletter.

Enter your email address:

Learn more

How money-savvy are you?

Will your choices help you reach your financial goals?

Try our Financial habits quiz.

Take action

Are you on track to meet your financial and retirement planning goals?

It's never too early or too late to start!

For a FREE review of your financial plan: Talk to an Advisor.

blacknail on

McKinsey’s thinks that resource scarcity is already here, this report might want to review the risk on that.

Brian on

What a time to make a great life changing investment in real estate for a young person. Why rent when you can lock in a 5 year closed mortgage rate close to 3%. Everyone knows interest rates will eventually rise and might double in 5 years but 6% ?? Far cry from the 15.5% I paid to buy a house in 1982. Even if rates start to rise, so will inflation, thus house prices will follow as it did in 1982 to 1990 when I sold my 8 year house for twice what I paid for. So will salaries. In 1990 rates were still way more than 6%. I used to dream about 6% rates back in 1982…we are half that now. Everyone is panicking or comparing us to USA. Come on, when this period is gone, it will be gone for 30-40 years. Now is the time to take advantage of it. In any case, banks still won;t lend money to us unless you prove you do not need it.

    Kevin Press on

    Thanks Brian. You make a fair point. Clearly, policy makers are rewarding borrowers and punishing savers with interest rates this low. As long as one maintains a reasonable amount of debt (David’s right about the value of the CMHC guidelines), it is possible to take advantage of this unique economic environment. On the five-year fixed though, check out my interview with Peter Majthenyi of Mortgage Architects in Toronto: http://brighterlife.ca/2012/01/23/why-you-should-consider-a-fixed-rate-mortgage/

David on

The European market is a definite concern. The problem with the euro is that member countries of the European Union wanted to include as many countries as possible, thinking that this would increase the clout of the euro. Unfortunately, some countries (like Greece) should have never adopted it. There are so many factors that a nation needs to agree to and monitor in order to adopt the euro, and the government needs to insure that these factors are controlled (inflation, interest rates, etc.). I think the euro is a good idea, but only for strong economies.

I also think there is a concern in Canada with the amount of debt that Canadians are accumulating. I am of the belief that a person should not accumulate debt that is greater than 40% of his/her income (as is indicated by CMHC). Any more debt can be detrimental to the individual, especially in these uncertain times. One of the problems is that this is the ‘now’ generation, and people are taking on debt not realizing that interest rates will eventually rise (which will potentially lead to more defaults on loans and mortgages).

    Kevin Press on

    Thanks David. My hunch is that we’ll continue to learn lessons from the eurozone for years to come. For example, government debt has traditionally been viewed as a safer investment than corporate debt because sovereigns can always pay their obligations (by printing money if need be). Eurozone countries don’t have that luxury. Because the European Central Bank is not mandated to act as a lender of last resort, the bonds issued by countries like Greece and Portugal are inherently riskier than government debt issued outside the region.

Add a new comment:

Note: Please be sure to read our commenting policy and terms and conditions for this site. We reserve the right to delete any comments that we view to be in violation of our policy. The name you provide will appear next to your comment. Thank you!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Advisor Match
Free newsletter subscription
Sun Life is Reader's Digest most-trusted life insurance brand

Connect to your Brighter Life